College Football Week 5 – Review

College Football Week 5 – Review
Reading Time: 3 minutes.

Andy Normile reacts to week 5 of the college football season.

Another exciting and entertaining weekend in college football, and one which raised the intrigue and expectations for future weeks.

Top 3 – but in which order:

The top 3 teams (Alabama, Georgia and Ohio State) have clearly established themselves as the best 3 teams in the country. But, in which order to rank those 3 is far more problematical. All three have had impressive wins, but also have at times looked vulnerable, so separating them is not easy.  

Image Credit: News and Advance

The debate was further widened by Georgia’s narrow win over 26-22 win over Missouri. A team they would have been expected to beat comfortably. Alabama were more comfortable over Arkansas, but remember they struggled to beat Texas, and although Ohio State thrashed Rutgers, they were less than convincing against Notre Dame. Any of these teams could equally be ranked 1,2 or 3. At least we have a 4-team playoff to avoid any glaring or controversial omissions.

The best of the rest: 

So, at this stage in the season, who would get that vital 4th spot? Again, very difficult to determine especially as Michigan, USC and Clemson all had impressive wins. Although it’s worth noting the Tigers now have successive victories over ranked teams, which the other 2 don’t. Both Michigan and USC have the harder parts of their schedules to come, games against Penn State and Utah respectively in the next 2 weeks will be crucial.

Look who else is unbeaten:

College Football
Image Credit: SI

As usual, the vagaries of scheduling mean there are several surprise unbeaten teams. Who would have predicted any of Syracuse, Kansas, TCU and UCLA to all be unbeaten this far let alone all four of them? How long they will remain unbeaten is debatable, but they haven’t come this far by chance. Kansas showed they can play defence, holding Iowa State to just 11 points. TCU looked equally impressive romping to a 55-24 thrashing over Oklahoma and UCLA beat a very good Washington team. Chances are they will all lose sooner rather than later, but the possibility of a Cinderella season is still alive. The Big 12 looks especially fascinating given Oklahoma State are also unbeaten and Kansas State are 4-1. Indeed this week’s Red River Rivalry game between Texas and Oklahoma has become the equivalent of a 3-point relegation battle.  

Comeback teams:

A quick glance at some of the 4-1 teams, highlights a couple of schools that have bounced back from early season losses. Utah and Oregon looked impressive with wins over Oregon State and Stanford. We’ve seen in the past that the selection committee is more likely to forgive an early season blip. So, if either of these teams were to win out and claim the Pac-12 title, the playoff door is very much ajar. 

Battle in Group of 5:

College Football
Image Credit: Down The Drive

The top spot for the best Group of 5 teams is also wide open (unlike last year when it was Cincinnati from day 1). Memphis, Tulane and Cincinnati all look strong in the AAC, but, don’t forget Coastal Carolina (who last year made it as high as 14 in the rankings) and James Madison are both unbeaten in the Sun Belt. 

This week might not have given us any decisive clues as to the final winners and losers of the season, but it has certainly whetted our appetite.

Thanks to Andy for producing week 5’s College Football Review. You can see more of his work here in the future!

You can also check out our full list of 2023 NFL Draft Scouting Reports here

Feature Image Credit: SBNation

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Back to top
%d bloggers like this: