Is the Super Bowl hangover real? By Rhys Knott

Is the Super Bowl hangover real? By Rhys Knott
Reading Time: 5 minutes.

Is the Super Bowl hangover real?

During the 1990’s and 2000’s the Premier League provided entertainment and occasionally controversy. But there was rarely any suspense surrounding who would win the title. As Manchester United lifted the trophy eight times between 1992 and 2003. Then again five times between 2007 and 2013. That level of dominance is not usually a problem for the NFL. The last time a team won back-to-back titles was when the Patriots managed it in 2004 and 2005.

Parity is the watchword for the NFL. Which seems rather at odds with the USA’s general suspicion of the Communist ideology, but here we are. Usually this mantra pays off season in and season out as the NFL delivers a product which provides more twists and turns than the Cresta Run. Which proves more addictive than a Class A drug. Super Bowl Champions will almost certainly always experience some sort of “hangover” particularly early the next season. As a run to the Super Bowl sees their season extended by at least four games and condences their Offseason. The “parity” also impacts the following season too because, unlike MLB where teams are subject to a soft salary cap plus a “luxury tax”, a strict salary cap is an integral part of the NFL’s business plan.

Super Bowl hangover – a historical perspective

Using a more generous measure of what constitutes a “hangover” it’s possible to see that a Super Bowl appearance hasn’t historically spelled out disaster for a team’s subsequent season. 10 teams have made back to back Super Bowls. With Buffalo famously making four on the spin in the early 1990’s, two of which came before the NFL had adopted Unrestricted Free Agency. Of course the Bills famously lost all four of their appearances (the first by just a single point). But to keep coming back and taking AFC titles was an amazing achievement.

However it’s important to note the NFL adopted the salary cap rule in 1994 the year of Buffalo’s last appearance. And, theoretically, that’s where the tighter focus on “parity” began (the NFL Draft has been in place in 1936).

Salary Cap Era

Interestingly five different teams appeared in back to back Super Bowls before the advent of the salary cap. And it has also happened five times since 1994 (with the Patriots managing the feat twice in the last 28 years). In fact, since the introduction of the cap they are the only team to make three consecutive appearances.

Famously the Patriots run was aided by players settling for contracts well below their market value to be a part of “the Patriot Way.” So they are arguably somewhat of an anomaly. In all teams have appeared in consecutive Super Bowls 12 times in the Super Bowl era. So it happens roughly every five years and after the Chiefs managed it in 2020 and 2021 it’s not due to happen again before 2026 (but the Chiefs will be doing their best to buck that trend).

Last year’s Super Bowl teams

Last season’s Super Bowl teams are really proving just how much a deep playoff run takes out of a team and how difficult it is to make it back to the big show. They both have 3-3 records and the Rams are really struggling to score points in 2022. After Week 5 they ranked 29th in scoring, 1st in Sacks allowed and dead last in rushing yards so far this season.

At the same point of the season, the Bengals were slap bang in the middle when it comes to scoring as they’re ranked 16th. But they have also struggled to protect their Quarterback. They’re ranked 4th in the Sacks allowed category. Cincinatti’s Defence however is performing better than their NFC counterparts (they do say Defences wins titles). Plus they ranked 8th in terms of points allowed so their future is looking considerably brighter than the Rams’.

The Rams

The Rams current issues are largely of their own making as they sacrificed any future Draft capitol they had to trade for older players who would help them win the Super Bowl Sean McVay and Les Snead craved. The plan worked as they traded for Matthew Stafford, Von Miller, Sony Michel, Jalen Ramsey and gave L.A’s roster a strong “studs and duds” vibe.

But they didn’t have a single selection in the first 103 picks this year and currently they’ll have just two picks in the first five rounds next year. They currently possess a first-round pick in 2024’s Draft but with the potential for as many as seven Offensive Linemen deserving a first-round pick in 2023 it wouldn’t be a huge surprise if they traded that pick to bolster their pass protection sooner rather than later.

The Bengals

The Bengals quandry is more down to a freak injury (or illness) than an issue with their roster construction. At the end of last season the Cincinatti bandwagon was looking like a pretty reliable mode of transport for the immediate future. With a 25 year old Quarterback who’s contracted through 2024 and Ja’marr Chase who was 21 at the time of the Super Bowl heading up one of the best receiving trios in the league. All complementing a Defence that had managed to do what few others could do last season and slow down Patrick Mahomes. The future looked bright and indeed Orange for the Bengals. However, as Robert Burns once wrote, the best laid plans of mice and men often go awry.

During the Offseason they signed three Free Agent Offensive Linemen and Drafted Cordell Volson to add depth along the troublesome Offensive Line. A line that saw Burrow pressured on 41.5% of his snaps and Sacked seven times by the Rams (twice by Miller). But then in July Joe Burrow’s appendix ruptured just two weeks before preseason. Burrow didn’t feature at all during preseason. While it’s unlikely he would have played many snaps the new arrivals placed a premium on time on the field. New Linemen need to adapt to their colleagues and a new Quarterback. Likewise, the Quarterback needs to find a rhythm with a new Offensive Line blocking in front of him.

Essentially the first four games of the season replaced preseason and became the bedding in period for the new players. After six games, standing at 3-3 they may now be looking for an upward trajectory.

Super Bowl Hangover – now

In 2022 there has definitely been a “Super Bowl hangover.” Unlike this year so far, that hangover is usually worse for the losing team. But interestingly the two teams who lost in the Conference Championship games, the Chiefs and 49ers are the highest point scorers and the second stingiest Defence in the NFL respectively. So theoretically the Rams and Bengals should shake off the rust sooner or later (in the Rams case it may coincide with them re-signing Odell Beckham, only Cooper Kupp and Tyler Higbee have been consistent receiving threats and that allows opposing Defences to focus on defending against the run more than they can against if Beckham suits up).

Going forward team’s making consecutive Super Bowl appearances may become a more common occurrence as the league recovers from any pandemic losses and the salary cap increases (it’s currently projected to jump by $18 million to $20 million each year). While the trend towards young, mobile and exciting Quarterbacks allows teams to maintain a stable roster for three or maybe four years at a time. Or as Patrick Mahomes spends the next nine seasons dominating the AFC, who’s to say?

Guest writer Rhys Knott has already made some interesting contributions to the sitte. Read more of his work here.

Banner Image: Are the Rams & Bengals suffering a Super Bowl LVI hangover? Image from marca.com

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Back to top
%d bloggers like this: