When is a bad team not a bad team? By Rhys Knott

When is a bad team not a bad team? By Rhys Knott
Reading Time: 10 minutes.

When is a bad team not a bad team?

Bill Parcells famously said “you are what your record says you are.” That is cosmetically true. But exactly how much credence should we give to the words of a man who shares his nickname “the big tuna” with an infamous Chicago mobster? In the 2022 version of the NFL at least it seems that some team’s records are not always a true reflection of how good they are.

All teams can have games where they don’t do themselves justice. Or suffer misfortunes which cause them to underperform (usually officiating calls). This season quite a few teams appear to be struggling to play “complimentary football”. After a third of the season it may be possible to identify teams where one or two of the three phases function properly. Whilst the team is poorly let down by the other phases.

The bad teams – by record

The worst record in the NFL after 6 weeks is shared between four teams. The Texans and Lions (who are at various stages of rebuilding). The Panthers (who began yet another rebuilding process just last week and frankly have been on the slide since Luke Kuechly retired in 2019). Plus the Raiders who do have a new Head Coach but seem better prepared for success than most.

Of those teams only the Texans and the Panthers (who now have a Defensively minded Head Coach) find themselves in the bottom five of the league for Offensive production. The Lions are 15th in the league (so the top half). You’d also expect everyone at the bottom of the league to be struggling to score points. But again only the Panthers and Texans are in the bottom five in terms of points per game. Las Vegas are sixth and the Lions surprisingly for a so-called bad team are third.

Bad teams have different issues to each other

On the other side of the ball nobody has conceded more points per game than the Lions. With an average of 34 points per game (ppg), no need to guess where they need to improve then. Three teams have a worse points differential but no team has conceded more touchdowns than Detroit with 21.

Houston’s Defence is considerably better. As you’d expect from a Lovie Smith team. Smith after all was one of Tony Dungy’s assistants when the “Tampa 2” Defence was devised. Their 13th ranked Defence is allowing 19.8 ppg (just one point more than the 7th ranked Patriots). And they’ve only conceded 4 touchdown passes in their six games.

In Carolina the Panthers have somehow constructed an average Defence that has conceded 15 touchdowns. The eighth lowest number in the league. But they have given up 12 first downs via penalties. Which is the seventh highest and something for Steve Wilks to get his teeth into immediately. The next worst Defence belongs to the Raiders. Who were allowing 25.8 ppg last year when they made the playoffs. And are worse this year as they’re conceding a nice round 26 ppg. Having allowed 11 touchdown receptions (three more than the Lions).

All three phases matter here

The final phase of the complimentary football equation is Special teams. While there isn’t usually a huge variance between average kick return distance every now and again a blocked field goal or punt return touchdown can swing momentum in a close game (remember the 49ers in Green Bay back in January?). Dan Campbell’s Lions have got the second longest kick return average this season. Which may be as a result of aggressive play calling they have only kicked four successful field goals, missing another two. This season they have an overall kicking success of 82%.

The Texans haven’t had to deal with the disruption at kicker others have. So as a result they’ve missed only one kick all season. With an overall 95% success rate, they’ve also got the 9th best kick return average. To go with the 11th best punt return average (safe to say Lovie Smith is quietly doing a very good job with very limited resources).

Accuracy not the issue

Similarly the Panthers have only missed one kick in 2022. With a 95% success rate. But they haven’t had as much joy in the return department. Their average punt return distance is 8.1 yards. Which sees them 17th in the league. But they have been more successful returning kickoffs, they stand seventh in the league with 23.7 yards per return.

Daniel Carlson might be the most reliable player in Las Vegas at the moment. As he’s only missed one extra point this season and knocked over every field goal he’s attempted. Including four from 50 yards or more, so the Raiders kicking success is 96%. Their kick return average is rated 16th in the league. But their punt return average is 31st at just 3.9 yards per return.

2 win teams

Outside the bottom four teams in the league eight teams are hot on their heels with just two wins. The Steelers who wrestled with who to start at Quarterback after Big Ben’s retirement (and subsequently had to make a change once Pickett suffered an injury). The Commanders who are just an absolute disaster from top to bottom. Especially as Ron Rivera seems more than happy to become a meat shield for Dan Snyder. The Browns also sit at 2-4 and are desperately challenging the Commies as the worst run franchise in the league.

The Bears are rebuilding like the Texans (in as much as there are green shoots of recovery but nobody is sure how long it’s going to take). The Jaguars are also rebuilding but they at least have some tools to use. The surprisingly “bad” teams so far in 2022 are the Cardinals, Saints and Broncos. Who all look to have what’s necessary to be a successful, if not dominant team.

Weird in Arizona

And this is where it gets a little weird – Prior to their 42 point outburst this week, the Cardinals had only scored 19 points per game. This with one of the most highly touted Offences and alleged Offensive guru Kliff Kingsbury in charge. (If you don’t believe that he is the Cardinals do. Just check out his new 4 year $22 million contract). That’s six fewer ppg than the Browns. The Cardinals lack of Offensive production can be explained away by the number of players they’re missing. Running Backs James Conner and Darrel Williams have suffered injuries. But Eno Benjamin was averaging 3.8 yards per carry and there’s certainly nothing wrong with Kyler Murray’s legs.

More important may be DeAndre Hopkin’s 6 game suspension. Although how an Offence is so reliant on the presence of a single player is perplexing when there’s a guru at the helm. Arizona also have four Offensive linemen on a list of 13 players currently injured. Which makes trading for Robbie Anderson even odder.

There is hope

But it’s not all terrible for the Cardinals. They’ve allowed just 623 yards rushing and that’s the sixth fewest in the league. Which sees them ranked alongside the Ravens. They’ve also only conceded 14 total touchdowns in 2022. Special teams wise they’ve been missing Matt Prater, that’s well known record breaker Matt Prater, with an injury. Prater’s been batting 1.000 in the games he’s played so far. He’s yet to miss but his replacement Matt Ammendola (guess they couldn’t be bothered to learn a new name?) is not as great. He’s missed one field goal and one extra point and he’s only started two games.

The Cardinals are struggling to return punts successfully too. With an average of 5.3 yards ranking them 27th. But they can return kicks, they’re ranked sixth in that department with an average return length of 23.8 yards. The return of Hopkins could help fire up that Offence. And perhaps if they get some injured players returning too. So if they can improve the punt returning a late resurgence could be on the cards.

Where scoring is the issue

The Bears are the penultimate team in the league when it comes to scoring with just 15.5 points per game. That’s understandable as their Quarterback is just 23, their coaching set up is completely new and none of their available receivers have more than five years experience in the NFL. They have been relatively lucky in terms of injuries so far this season though. As, while they do have three Wide Receivers on the Injured List none of Tajae Sharpe, David Moore or Byron Pringle are exactly Justin Jefferson.

New Head Coach Matt Eberflus was the Colts Defensive Coordinator before he took this job. Having previously worked as the Cowboys Linebackers coach (and passing game coordinator bizarrely). And the Bears have only conceded 13 touchdowns. They also have the most Quarterback hurries in the NFL despite blitzing less than any other team.

The Bears have some kicking woes too and considering how difficult it can be to kick at Soldier Field they’ve overcome them with relative ease. Cairo Santos and Michael Badgely both have a 100% record on field goals. Although Santos has missed two extra points (both in the torrential rainstorm that drenched Chicago in week 1). Punt returning has been one of their problems as they average just 4.4 yards per return, the third lowest total in the league. They’ve had more success returning kick offs but they are ranked just 20th sat between the Saints and Packers.

Injuries can have an impact

The Broncos are the only team below the Bears in the points scored per game category. With a lowly 15.2 and that’s going to happen when you lose a starting Running Back after just three and a half games and your Quarterback tears a muscle in his back in the same game. If they were the only two injuries the Broncos had suffered you’d think they’d been unlucky to lose three games by a total of eight points (especially considering Brandon McManus has missed Field Goals in two of those games).

They’re also missing Wide Receiver Tim Patrick who many expected would be their most reliable pass catcher. As well as Pass rusher Randy Gregory who they signed to a five year contract in the offseason. And finally, Super Bowl winning Cornerback Ronald Darby and All-Pro Left Tackle Garrett Bolles who broke his leg in week 5.

With so much disruption it’s not surprising the Offence has been pretty chaotic after six games. The saving grace for the Broncos in 2022 is new Defensive Coordinator Ejiro Evero.

As a former Rams Safeties coach, he has crafted a Defensive unit that has allowed just three passing touchdowns so far this season. Which is fewest in the league. Not to mention three rushing touchdowns too (third fewest). They’ve also recorded 19 Sacks. Which is the fourth most in the league. And the 16.5 points per game they’re allowing is the third fewest behind the Bills, 49ers and Cowboys. Who are all in the playoff mix.

They’re ranked 6th for punt returning as their 11 yards per return is best average of all the teams in the bottom 11 league places. But their 18.3 yard average kick off return not only means they have a longer field to work with than most it ranks them 30th in the league.

A bad start does not mean you are out of contention

Pittsburgh have the 3rd lowest points average with 16.2. But are only one win away from the top of their Division. So while they are technically bad they’re not far from being a team who confuses everyone and appears in the playoffs. The Steelers aren’t really missing many stars. But they are without their brightest in TJ Watt. Then again he could return for their last eight games. Four of which are Divisional games. So it’s hard to count them out.

Only four teams have forced more turnovers than Pittsburgh so far. And they’re all playoff teams; the Eagles, Patriots, Bills and Ravens. In the single game Watt started this season the Steelers recorded seven Sacks, made two interceptions, recovered a fumble and scored a Defensive touchdown. Chris Boswell is the highest paid kicker in the NFL. You’d like to think he wouldn’t miss many kicks between 30 and 39 yards then. But he’s missed in that range and two more between 40 and 49 yards. With an overall success rate of 83%. Their return game has been much help either, they’re 21st for punt returns and 26th for kickoff returns.

Ironically despite not having the worst scoring average the Commanders may well be one of those teams who are what their record says they are. They are actually averaging more than two scores per game on Offence. This despite having a Quarterback who seems to melt in the important situations (between the 5 yard line and endzone Carson Wentz has a completion rate of 43% and has thrown two touchdowns and an interception from his seven attempts). More worryingly they are allowing their opponents to score 22.5 ppg. They’ve also got an 83% success rate when it comes to kicking. They’re pretty average at returning punts too where they are ranked 15th and their average kick off of 20.9 yards is the 10th worst.

Inconsistency can be an issue

Jacksonville are where you would expect them to be as they recover from their abusive relationship with Urban Meyer. Quarterback Trevor Lawrence is ranked 15th for completion percentage. Which is above the likes of Derek Carr and Lamar Jackson. And his 65.5% rate is just 0.4% below Patrick Mahomes. It looks like the Jaguars are probably more of an inconsistent team than a bad one. Perhaps they will blossom into a playoff team in the coming seasons.

Defensively the Jaguars have a real issue getting off the field. In week 6 the Colts converted 10 of 15 3rd down chances for example. Overall this season opponents have converted 43.4% of the time. Which is terrible for a team who spent a number 1 pick on a Linebacker. The new Jags coaching regime in Jacksonville has retired Urban Meyer’s practice of kicking field goal kickers as they stretch. It seems to be paying dividends so far. 23 year old Riley Patterson has only missed one kick all year. But their return game needs some work as they’re ranked in the bottom 10 for both kick and punt returns.

In need of defensive improvement

Cleveland are in the running for the ‘worst Defence in the league’ title. Having allowed 19 total touchdowns and allowing an average of 27.2 points per game. That’s the second highest average (alongside the Seahawks). Their Nick Chubb led Offence has been very effective though. The 26 year old is averaging 5.9 yards per carry and has scored seven touchdowns this season. Now the Browns sit top of the league averaging 172 yards per game on the ground.

Rookie kicker Cade York has an overall success rate of 86%. Although he did miss two field goals in a game they lost by two points. They also have the fifth worst punt return average and are ranked just 17th for kick off returning.

Dennis Allen’s Saints team aren’t exactly having the best of luck this season. They double doinked a field goal that would have taken them to overtime at the Tottenham Stadium. And they’ve got five Defensive players on the Injured list, including three Defensive backs. This week they’ve got 14 players on an injury report that includes two Quarterbacks, three Wide receivers and four Offensive linemen. So it’s easy to see why they have only won two games all season.

Looking ahead

Six games isn’t a huge sample size in terms of statistics and the old Parcells quote may well prove to be more accurate later in the season. At the end of the season it will be undeniably true that the teams with the worst records are who we think they are.

The quote is attributed to Parcells in 1994. This when his Patriots team began the season with a three and six record. But after winning their final seven games they ended the season as a Wildcard team. So perhaps the real worth of the words is as a motivational tool rather than a true analysis.

Either way it will be fun to watch the latest NFL season unfold. So we can see which teams go on to success and which are the 2022 cellar dwellers.

If you enjoyed this article you can find more from Rhys Knott here.

Featured Image: Will the 1-4 Detroit Lions be remembered as a bad team at seasons’ end? Image from prideofdetroit.com

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Back to top
%d bloggers like this: