
Andy Normile reacts to week 8 of the college football season.
Another exciting and action-packed weekend in College Football, but did it give us some answers, or leave us with more questions?
Defence Still Wins Matches:
After last week when it seemed the only way to win a football match was to have the ball last and outscore the opponents, it was good to see some key matches decided by defence.
Clemson beat Syracuse 27-21, for a come from behind win after trailing 10-21 at the half, and shutting out the Orange offence for the whole of the 2nd half. Good job the defence, led by DT Brian Bresse played so well because the offence struggled. After a fine start to the season, DJ Uiagalelei had his worst game so far throwing 2 key INTs and was replaced by star freshman Cade Klubnik. Head coach Dabo Sweeney insisted after the game that DJ was still his No1 QB, but watch this space.
Clemson is now 6-0 in the conference and appears to have an easy path to the title game and playoffs, without looking anywhere near as convincing as its 2016 or 2018 title-winning teams, or indeed the other unbeaten teams. Indeed, if the Tigers were to slip up in any of their further games, they would appear to be behind any 1 loss SEC or Big 10 team, and out of contention.
If one of the days’ other big games, we also saw an impressive defensive game-winning performance form Oregon in their 45-30 win over the previously unbeaten UCLA. The Ducks’ defence held UCLA to their lowest points total this season and most importantly kept QB sensation Dorian Thompson-Robinson in check, limiting him to ‘just’ 262 yards, and preventing any of the spectacular plays he is renowned for. It also helped that the Ducks offence was also on fire, with Bo Nix passing for 5 TD’s and showing his star quality, without any of the mistakes, which have blighted previous outings.
Still in the Playoff Picture:
With their win, Oregon boosted their playoff hopes and proved like several teams there is still life for a 1 loss team. The Ducks look like the strongest team in the Pac-12, they still have tough games ahead against Utah, Oregon State and the Pac-12 title game (USC ?) but win all those and it would be easy to forgive their opening day loss to Georgia, especially if the Bulldogs go unbeaten.
Perhaps the team that did the most to boost their playoff hopes was LSU, who were very impressive in beating the previously unbeaten Ole Miss, again another match featuring some excellent defence, with the Rebels being held scoreless in the 2nd half. While Tigers QB Jayden Daniels now looks at home and is confident with Brian Kelly’s offence, passing for 2 TDs and rushing for 3 more. LSU now own their destiny in the SEC West with a game against Alabama in 2 weeks’ time being key. Win that and they should find themselves in the conference title game against maybe Tennesse, with the chance to redeem an earlier season loss. Now a 2 loss SEC champion Tigers team, would make for a very interesting discussion.
And of course, Alabama put last week’s woes behind them, to convincingly beat Mississippi State, and set up that key match against the vastly improving LSU.
Oklahoma State also rebounded from last week’s defeat, to beat Texas in a see-saw contest. The rest of their schedule looks relatively light, but they still have unbeaten TCU in their way. TCU looked strong in defeating Kansas State, if the Horned Frogs can beat Texas and win the title game while remaining unbeaten their playoff place would look to be assured.
What Happened to..?:
Preseason rankings are always fraught with danger, this year’s rankings included Texas A&M at 6, Miami at 16 at Pittsburgh at 17, something that now looks a long way off.
The Aggies struggled to find any offence in a surprise loss to S. Carolina and are now 3-4. Pittsburgh’s inconsistent season continued as they lost to Louisville, which means unless they beat N Carolina next week, they can give up any hope of repeating as ACC champions. But the biggest fall belongs to Miami, who gave up a shocking 8 turnovers in their loss to Duke as well as losing star QB Tyler Van Dyke to a shoulder injury.
Also:
Cincinnati continues to look like the best team in the Group of 5, especially after UCF’s surprising heavy defeat to East Carolina, their biggest threat now appears to come from Tulane who continue their amazing turnaround season (last year they were 2 -10) and coincidental play the Bearcats in the final game of the season, before a potential title game rematch. But also keep an eye out for Liberty, who compete as an independent, but are now 7-1 after thrashing BYU (another pre-season ranked team who have suffered a mighty fall) and could claim the Big 6 bowl berth, should Cincinnati slip up.
Playoff Picture:
At the moment the college football playoff picture looks like:
- Winner of Georgia v Tennesse
- Winner of Ohio State v Michigan
- Clemson – if they stay undefeated
- TCU – if they stay undefeated
If Clemson or TCU were to lose, then their place would most likely be taken by the best one-loss SEC, best one-loss Big 10 team or Pac 12-winning Oregon.
Now things would really get interesting if Clemson and TCU both win out, but play poorly, and the one loss SEC or Big 10 look good. And just suppose LSU as a two-loss team were to win the SEC – well, then potential chaos, but then again only a few weeks ago we had Texas A&M, Pittsburgh and Miami in the top 20. Let the fun and games begin.
Thanks to Andy for producing week 8’s College Football Review. You can see more of his work here in the future!
You can also check out our full list of 2023 NFL Draft Scouting Reports here
