
- by Guest Writer
Rushing Quarterbacks – who are or have been the best in the NFL?
On the face of it, to claim Justin Fields is Michael Vick 2.0 (on the field anyway) appears plain lazy. But the fact remains that they are the only Quarterbacks to make mutliple appearances in the top 10 list of most rushing yards in a single game. Fields 178 yards (on 15 attempts) in week nine leads that list. Unsurprisingly Vick is second with 173 (from 10 attempts) in week 12 of the 2002 season.
Vick also has the third most in a game. As he recorded 166 (on 12 attempts) against the Saints in 2006. Fields’ second appearance in the list comes at seventh. With the 147 he racked up against the Lions just one week after his record breaking 178 (no wonder he’s suffering now). Vick also makes a third appearance in the top 10. But he played for 13 years and Justin Fields has just 21 games under his belt.
Obviously Vick and Fields share an exceptional level of athleticism. Vick ran a 4.33 40 yard dash at the Combine and Fields clocked a 4.43 at a Pro day. But that’s not the only thing they share, statistically there are also similarities. Fields’ averages 152.7 passing yards per game compared to Vick’s 157.1. Their touchdown percentages are eerily close too. With Vick’s 4.1% being almost identical to Fields’ 4.0%. Vick’s passer rating was 80.4 when he retired compared to Justin Fields 79.2. Fields currently has a 3.6% interception rate and Vick’s final interception rate was 2.7%.
Vick’s completion rate at the end of his career was 56.2% and Fields’ completion rate so far in his short career is 59.2%. Fields plays on a team who have been finding their identity for most of his career. In Atlanta Vick won nine games in his first two seasons. While Fields is working with such a revolving line-up he’s only been able to win five of his first 21. So far Fields has rushed for 54.5 yards per game compared to Vick’s 42.7. So it’s difficult to argue those two aren’t the best running Quarterbacks in modern history. Whatever order you care to place them in.
It only became legal to throw a forward pass in 1906 a full 37 years after the first game played. Even after it was allowed there were numerous rules that made running the best way of matriculating the ball down the field. Passes could not be thrown or caught within five yards of the line of scrimmage. Only players at the end of the line of scrimmage could catch the ball. And any pass that crossed the goal line resulted in a touchback for the defending team. The more recent rule changes designed to protect Quarterbacks in order to ensure the NFL provides an entertaining product every week have inadvertently encouraged athletic Quarterbacks to run more than they previously would have. (Unless they played in the 19th Century).
The five Quarterbacks with the most rushing yards in NFL history are Vick (obviously). Alongside Cam Newton, Randall Cunningham, (who played for 16 years and retired in 2002), who would have been a revelation in today’s NFL. Then Russell Wilson and Lamar Jackson round out the top five. So it’s very difficult to remove recency bias from this selection.
Beyond the top two rushing quarterbacks
The next three in the top five are very much up for debate and different rushing statistics feature various different quarterbacks. Cam Newton holds two records, the most rushing touchdowns in a season and the most in a career. His 14 in 2011 is the single season record. (He is also tied for second in that list with 12 in 2020 the same number as Steve Grogan for the 1976 Patriots when there were just 14 games in a season). Newton’s 75 rushing touchdowns is 32 more than Steve Young who is second. Allied to being second for most career rushing yards Newton’s 38 yards per game average is the fourth highest. All of that combined is enough to place him third in this top five.
Lamar Jackson has the highest average number of yards per game at 63.8. That’s a whole 21 yards more than second place Vick and this is where it starts to get messy. Josh Allen also features at third on that list. Jackson also holds the record for the most rushing attempts in a season by a quarterback with 176 in 2019. Not only is he first in that list he’s second and third with 159 in 2020 and 147 in 2018. The only other modern Quarterbacks who appear near the top of that particular category are Cam Newton, Jalen Hurts with 139 attempts in 2021 and Kyler Murray with 133 in 2020. Since Jackson features four times in the top nine he has to be in the top five and by the time his career ends. He may well be top of the list.
The top names in the rushing attempts per season list who are definitely not classed a modern Quarterbacks are Bill Shepherd and Bobby Douglass. Shepherd who played for Boston and Detroit. In 1935 Shepherd competed just 28 passes in the nine games he started that season. So you can see how it’s difficult to compare eras. Douglass set his total of 141 more recently than Shepherd. But in his 1972 season he started 14 games and only attempted 198 passes. (With a completion rate of 37.9% in the days where defending against receivers was brutal with a capital “B”). In his record breaking season Jackson threw 401 passes.
Josh Allen, Jalen Hurts’ and Kyler Murray are the other Quarterback battling it out for a spot in the top five. Recency bias, remember? Josh Allen has never scored more than nine rushing touchdowns in a season. But he does have the highest average yards per carry of any modern Quarterback. He’s behind Cunningham, Young and Vick but none of them have played in the last seven years. And his average of 39.5 yards per game is higher than everyone’s except Vick.
Kyler Murray is third on the single season touchdown list with three others who all scored 11 touchdowns in a single season. Hurts 10 rushing touchdowns in 2021 is fourth on the list of most in a season. That’s behind two of Cam Newton’s season’s in 2011 and 2020. And the 11 that Kyler Murray scored again in 2020. Of the three of them Murray has the highest average per attempt. His 5.8 yards is over half a yard more than Hurts’ 5.1 and just ahead of Allen’s 5.7. Plus, Murray’s running is more important to his team than the other two. Especially since it’s usually saves the Cardinals from their inept play calling. Either converting a third and long or saving them from 2nd and long down situations.
Jalen Hurts is one of the most important weapons in the Eagles running game though. And he’s been clinical in goal line situations and should set a new personal best for touchdowns this season. Allen on the other hand is a little bit of both. But given his proclivity for serious injuries the Bills will only want him running as a last resort for the remainder of the season. Making him so unlikely to improve on the nine touchdowns he recorded in 2019. Purely based on the season he’s having in 2022 Hurts is the fifth Quarterback in this list as he could finish the season with 187 attempts, 740 yards and 14 touchdowns.
Feel free to disagree and give us your top fives in the comments.
Rhys Knott has already made some interesting contributions to the sitte. Read more of his work here.
Banner Image: Rushing quarterback the Chicago Bears’ Justin Fields. Image from chicagosuntimes.com
