
Andy Normile reacts to a huge week 13 of college football.
To the uninitiated, football is just a physical game, huge guys crashing, smashing and beating the hell out of each other. But once you get to understand the fundamentals, you also appreciate it is just as much a game of chess
And with that regard Jim Harbaugh and Lincoln Riley are Grandmasters.
Big 10
Coming into the game, everyone (especially Ohio State) knew that Michigan’s modus operandi was to dominate the line of scrimmage and run the ball and then run the ball again.
So, what did Jim Harbaugh do? He rewrote the script, put the game in the hands of QB JJ McCarthy and threw the ball all over the Horseshoe. And just when the Buckeyes had figured this out, he went back to the running game and ran the ball all over the Horseshoe.
At the same time, he manoeuvred and adjusted his defence and kept the Buckeyes to just 3 2nd half points.
The final score of 45 -23 was one of the most overwhelming and decisive in the long history of ‘The Game’. It carries the Wolverines to the Big 10 championship game and makes them genuine title contenders.
For the Buckeyes, their playoff place is now very precarious, and CJ Stroud’s Heisman is in tatters.
Predictably the Big 10 West, came down to who managed not to lose.
Iowa failed to beat Nebraska because once again their offence couldn’t score.
Which meant it was left to Purdue to slip into the title game against Michigan next week. Surely one of the most mismatched title games in the playoff era, but in football, anything can happen.
So, Who Wants 4th?
Georgia and TCU kept their unbeaten seasons alive (TCU in a very un-TCU fashion, in that they led from start to finish) with Michigan’s dominating performance these three are certain of the top 3 places in the rankings.
Which leaves a debate as to who will get the final 4th place in the playoffs.
LSU had designs, a victory over Georgia in the SEC championship probably would have got them in, but they forgot about Texas A&M, and somehow allowed the Aggies to score 38 points in a disastrous loss. A 2-loss SEC champ might have gotten into the playoffs but a 3-loss team, no chance.
Clemson had an outside chance but also suffered a disastrous loss to in-state rivals S Carolina, who have now eliminated 2 teams in the space of 2 weeks.
What about USC?
Well, they couldn’t have done any more, in a dominating and decisive victory over bitter rivals Notre Dame. Like a chess Grandmaster, Lincoln Riley has been accumulating all the best pieces and putting them in vital positions on the board. His key piece Caleb Williams put on a masterclass, who was too quick and out thought the Notre Dame defence. His 232 yards passing, 3 running TDs and even punting were done with style and purpose, and in the presence of a nationally televised audience, which will almost certainly clinch him the Heisman. USC will now play Utah in the conference title game after Oregon fell apart in a loss to Oregon State, allowing the Beavers to come from behind with 28 unanswered points.
Which leaves the 4th spot between USC and Ohio State up for debate.
USC or Ohio State?
So, who gets that 4th spot?
Based on the usual and recognised criteria, the head-to-head comparison looks like this:
Strength of Schedule: USC has wins over 3 ranked teams (Notre Dame, UCLA, Oregon State). Ohio State has 2 (Notre Dame and Penn State).
Common Opponent: Both have similarly impressive wins over Notre Dame.
Losses: USC’s loss was by one point to Utah (who ran a last-minute two-point conversion), which is a lot closer than Ohio State’s 22-point defeat to Michigan.
Conference Championship: If USC beat Utah in the Championship game, they will be the ones with a championship, they will also have another win over a ranked team, and have avenged their regular season loss to the Utes.
Eye Test: Currently has to be the Trojans
So based on the above criteria and if they win the Pac-12, USC would appear to be the pick for 4th spot.
Of course, should TCU fail to win its conference title game, the door for Ohio State is open again?
Other Conference Title Games :
ACC: Clemson v N Carolina:
Although a championship game, this has no playoff implications, only an Orange Bowl place. The ACC currently looks like the weakest conference. If you consider that Kentucky beat a ranked Louisville, and S Carolina (arguably the 6th best team in the SEC) beat Clemson (arguably the best team in ACC). Indeed, the title game will be played by teams who are both coming off losses to their in-state rival. On current form, Florida State can claim to be the best team in the conference, and an early bet for next season.
SEC: Georgia v LSU:
Win or lose, it looks certain Georgia will be in the playoffs, while a 3-loss LSU won’t be considered even if they win this game. Remember Georgia entered last season’s SEC title game in a similar position being unbeaten in the regular season, but lost to Alabama, before eventually going on to win the national title.
BIG 12: TCU v Kansas State:
TCU will be desperate to preserve their unbeaten season and confirm their place in the playoffs. It is arguable that if TCU were to lose, they could be usurped by Ohio State. It’s also worth remembering Kansas State had an 18-point lead over TCU in their regular season game.
AAC: Tulane v UCF :
This look like an eliminator for a New Year’s Big 6 bowl as well as the American title.
Tulane will have a home advantage and will be looking to avenge a loss to UCF 2 weeks ago.
Also:
There was impressive rivalry wins for Mississippi State, Washington (which clinched Utah’s place in the conference title game), Penn State, and Minnesota.
While in probably his last college game Bijan Robinson proved he is the best RB in the game.
The 2022 regular season has been fantastic. It produced all the excitement, action and surprises that we have come to expect from College Football. Now onto the conference title games, Bowl mania and the playoffs.
Thanks to Andy for producing week 13’s College Football Review. You can see more of his work here in the future!
You can also check out our full list of 2023 NFL Draft Scouting Reports here
