Does it matter who is the 49ers quarterback? By Rhys Knott

Does it matter who is the 49ers quarterback? By Rhys Knott
Reading Time: 4 minutes.

Does it matter who is the 49ers quarterback?

Does it really matter who is the 49ers QB? Or do they have a system built for success? Kyle Shanahan’s offences have changed year on year either by accident or design. But since he’s been in San Francisco he’s had to adapt his system to suit the plethora of players involved. (Personnel has changed both in-between and during seasons due to the number of injuries). By and large it’s worked. In an era when the NFL is commonly referred to as a “quarterback league” is Shanahan bucking the trend?

2008 was his first season as an offensive coordinator in Houston. His starting quarterback on that occasion was Matt Schaub. Schaub went 6-5 but a knee injury saw Sage Rosenfels replace him for five games. That version of Shanahan’s offence threw the ball on 54% of their snaps. While 70% of their yards came through the air along with 57% of their touchdowns. They averaged 23 points per game. But ended the season with a negative points differential. Which may be the reason they threw the ball more often. 

In 2011 he was the offensive coordinator in Washington (working under some bloke called Mike). There Rex Grossman was the starting quarterback. Who was physically similar to Jimmy Garoppolo standing at six feet 1 and 225 pounds. Again, Shanahan changed starting quarterbacks mid-season. This after Grossman threw four interceptions and no touchdowns against the Eagles. John Beck replaced Grossman for three games. Which Washington lost. Grossman wasn’t as accurate as Garoppolo. (Clealry illustrated by those four interceptions in one game). Even so in 2011 he gained on average 242.4 yards per game. 70% of Washington’s yards in 2011 came from pass plays and they threw the ball 57% of the time their offence was on the field. Shanahan’s offence in Washington averaged just 18 points per game in 2011. Their 5-11 record did however allow them to draft Robert Griffin III. And that’s where the Shanahan fun really began.  

In 2012 Washington only threw the ball 44% of the time. But their 3,422 passing yards accounted for 56% of their total yards. They scored 46 touchdowns, fifth most in the league and 54% of those scores came through the air. RGIII’s particular set of skills allowed Shanahan to use the quarterback as a potent running threat for the first time. Griffin had 120 rushing attempts. Scoring seven touchdowns and averaging 6.8 yards per attempt.

Alfred Morris had 335 attempts for 1,613 yards and 13 touchdowns as Washington ran the ball 519 times. The previous season Grossman ran just 20 times and averaged 0.8 yards per attempt. Washington used four different running backs in 2012 who combined for 1,489 yards as the team amassed 300 total attempts. RGIII also suffered injuries during his rookie season. A concussion in week 5 and a sprained knee in week 14. Yet he didn’t miss any time and it was his bravery that ultimately caused the premature end to his career. 

Jumping ahead to Shanahan’s time in San Francisco Garoppolo has the highest completion rate of all his 49er quarterbacks. At 67.6% he’s behind only Drew Brees in terms of the highest career completion rate in the NFL. Before he suffered his injury, he was completing 67.2% of his passes this season, ninth best in the league. His yards per attempt (7.9) is fourth highest in the league behind only Tagovailoa, Hurts and Mahomes. He is also ranked fourth in terms of interception rate this season at 1.3%. Just 0.3% behind Daniel Jones who leads the league in 2022. Garoppolo’s 2022 passer rating was the fifth best in the league behind Tagovailoa, Geno Smith, Mahomes and Hurts. All of which makes you wonder what the 49ers were thinking when they tried to trade him. 

During Shanahan’s stint in San Francisco five other quarterbacks have started games. But apart from Trey Lance (who has only started four games in two seasons) they are all remarkably similar. It’s safe to say Shanahan has a type. Mullens and Purdy are both 6 feet 1. Garoppolo, Hoyer and Beathard are all 6 feet 2 and they all weigh between 210 pounds and 225 pounds. Trey Lance is 6 feet 4 but even he fits the weight criterion. As he weighs in at 224 pounds (one pound lighter than Garoppolo).  

It’s not just Lance’s height that is an outlier though. His numbers are substantially different to everyone else’s. He has a completion rate of just 55% (worse than even Hoyer’s). But averages 29.4 rush yards per game (nobody else is above 12.5). In Washington Griffin averaged 54.3 yards per game and Lance gains on average just 99.6 yards per game.  

Generally, 49ers quarterbacks under Shanahan have all been accurate passers who move the ball efficiently. Garoppolo obviously the most accurate. Although Brock Purdy is just behind him at 66.7%. Garoppolo gains 238 yards per game. Which is technically second to Nick Mullens’ 248.1 yards. But he started just 16 games in San Francisco compared to Garoppolo’s 55. And Mullens had peak George Kittle catching his passes. 

Brock Purdy has obviously only started two games in his rookie season. But he’s played in six all together and attempted 93 passes. It’s not just his completion rate that is impressive so far. He gains 113 yards per game, he’s only rushed 15 times (and a number of those attempts will be him taking the knee) and as a result he averages 0.2 yards per carry. So he’s definitely not a direct Lance replacement. 

San Francisco have the most suffocating defense in the league this season. Which is the key to their success. The 286 yards they allow per game is the fewest in the NFL. They have even recorded more interceptions (14) than they have conceded touchdowns (13). Their run defense is almost airtight too. They allow just 3.4 yards per carry. Having conceded just nine rushing touchdowns in 14 games this season. And only three teams have made more turnovers than their 22. 

The most important person in that defensive unit is Arik Armstead. In the six games he has played in 2022 the 49ers have conceded an average of 12 points per game and have only lost once (in a monsoon at Soldier Field way back on week one). In the six games that both Armstead and Nick Bosa have started Bosa has recorded nine sacks, in the eight games Bosa has played without Armstead in the defensive line he’s recorded 6.5 sacks.

Perhaps then Armstead’s presence is very much the key to the 49ers success in 2022 not the quarterbacks. After all, whoever is under center has the Shanahan input to fall back on.

If you enjoyed this article you can find more from Rhys Knott here.

Banner Image: Current 49ers quarterback Brock Purdy. Image from NFL.com

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Back to top
%d bloggers like this: