
- by Chris Lawton
What is wrong with the Packers
Over the last decade the Packers have been to drama what Alfred Hitchcock was to suspense. So it’s not even remotely surprising there’s a touch of Janet Leigh taking a quick shower about the last six months in Green Bay. The Pack as they’re also known currently sit second in the NFC North. Two games out of a Wildcard slot. Which isn’t great by their lofty standards. This is a team after all that has gone 39-10 over the past three seasons. Making it to within a game of the Superbowl twice.
There’s still time to turn it around. They can’t afford to lose another Divisional game though. It helps that they still have two games to play against the Lions. Who, if current form is anything to go by couldn’t win a coin toss with a double headed coin. Recent form is the Packers biggest issue though. And a team who has made their Quarterback the fifth highest paid in the league shouldn’t be losing three consecutive games.
Every team who leads an NFL division after seven weeks of the 2022 season has a focal point of their Offence. Well, except the Buccaneers who are sort of winning a division by accident. Either a Wide Receiver who has caught more than four touchdowns (or Justin Jefferson who averages 109 receiving yards per game). Or a Running Back who has scored more than four touchdowns. Seattle have opted for the old fashioned two-headed monster in the backfield who have combined for six touchdowns and both average 6.1 yards per carry. Or a Jalen Hurts who’s notched up six rushing touchdowns.
The Packers focal point is problematic
The Packers’ focal point seems to be Aaron Rodgers and when every Defence concentrates on upsetting or stopping the Quarterback that’s problematic. It’s even more problematic when you consider Rodgers is never that far from a major on field meltdown, or from having some sort of existential crisis off the field.
Everyone has had their fair share of personal issues over the last 17 years and Rodgers is no different. He reportedly hasn’t spoken to his family since 2014. Although nobody knows why it’s believed they were offended by his public criticism of Christianity.
More recently he’s been making headlines across for the world for claiming to be “immunised” and latterly because his latest romantic interest claims to be a witch. And then again when he revealed his first tattoo that has a sort of metaphysical, astrological theme. Not to mention in August when it was reported he’d been on at least two “retreats” in Peru where he’d partaken in the ceremonial spiritual medicine ayahuasca tea. A tea that contains the hallucinogenic substance Dimethyltryptamine (DMT), that is a Class A drug in America. Rodgers told Peter King the psychoactive drug had “changed his life”. The Guardian reported “a lot of healing went on” and Amanda Taylor wrote in People magazine that “Rodgers’ ayahuasca journey isn’t over”.
A diva in the North?
All highly motivated Quarterbacks exhibit some Diva behaviour and Rodgers doesn’t have the best poker face. He’s not adverse to flinging a tablet computer around on the sidelines. If he feels there’s a problem with his teammates play or the play-calling he’s never shy to express his displeasure.
His ‘individuality’ has also appeared when he’s dealt with the Packers front office. In 2018 he and his agent tried to negotiate a salary that would tie in each year in direct correlation to the annual increase in the team’s salary cap. Whilst the team turned that idea down it may have actually saved them money in the long term as Rodgers latest contract accounts for 13.25% of the Packers salary cap. If Rodgers were to leave Green Bay it would incur a dead cap hit of over $151 million. Meaning it looks like they’re stuck with him. It’s not just Rodgers’ contract that raises questions about the Packers talent evaluation skills and how they construct a roster though. We’ll explore that in more detail later.
Obviously it takes more than one player to make a team. But, when one player accounts for so much of a teams capital they are really expecting an on field return on their investment. As the most high profile member (if not the focal point) of the team Rodgers is going to be the one who draws the adulation that comes with success and the ire when it’s not going well. That’s regardless of his actual performance. But is he actually playing well?
Rodgers needs some help from his teammates
Rodgers is 10th in the list of passing yards this season and his interception rate of 1.2% is fourth best in the NFL. Sitting him behind only the GOAT Tom Brady. Plus Daniel Jones and Jalen Hurts who predominantly run first. But he has been Sacked 5.8% of the times he’s dropped back and just one team has dropped more passes than the Packers so far in to 2022. That’s the Dolphins (who have had three different starting Quarterbacks and have one more drop having thrown three more passes).
The Packers are also the only NFL team who have two Receivers in the top in terms of fumbles. Amari Rodgers (no relation) has dropped the ball four times (the most in the league). While rookie Romeo Doubs has relinquished possession twice too. The other factor is the absence of Davante Adams. Rodgers has yet to throw for 300 yards this season. He did that four times in 2021. Davante Adams notched up over 100 receiving yards in all those games (he went for 205 yards against the Bengals).
The standout difference between 2022 Aaron Rodgers and the Aaron Rodgers of the past is how little he has run the ball. That may be as a result of the Packers new Offensive coaches. Or, may hint to him carrying an injury. Rodgers has scored rushing touchdowns in 12 of the 14 seasons that he’s been the starter in Green Bay. And, apart from 2017 (one of the seasons he was injured) he has rushed at least 30 times every season. He’s currently on pace to run the ball just 23 times this season.
The Packers coaching rebuild
After losing 2022’s Offensive Coordinator, Quarterback coach and Tight End coach the Packers coaching team are going through their own mini rebuild. Whilst it really should have settled down after 10 games there still seems to be teething problems. The Packers have won 13 games in each of the last three seasons. That has coincided with them increasing the number of run plays they’ve called. Obviously there was an extra game last season so there were extra plays full stop.
In 2019 they ran the ball 411 times. A 19% increase on 2018 (when they ended the season with a 6-9-1 record). In 2020 they increased that by seven percent to 443. However this season they are currently on pace to run the ball just 403 times and pass 607. Which would be the most since 2018 (and we know how that ended).
Bringing in the running game
The intruiging part is that new Offensive Coordinator Adam Stenavich was promoted from the role of “offensive line coach and running game coordinator.” So it’s not that he doesn’t understand how important the run game is to this Packers plan. It’s more likely when the team goes behind on the scoreboard he feels the pressure in his new role. Quickly abandoning his modus operandi in order to regain the lead as quickly as possible. Leading to a never-ending Catch 22 situation.
Aaron Jones has been on the field for 63% of the Packers Offensive snaps this season and AJ Dillon 48% of the time. They are collectively responsible for 40% of the team’s yards. It appears that if Stenavich can involve those two more the Offence will become more productive. Even if Jones or Dillon aren’t the players used to move the ball their presence keeps the Defence honest in play-action situations. Which could even free up Rodgers to run the ball more himself.
What about the front office?
Rodgers may not be an effective focal point for the Packers Offence. But he is absolutely a focal point for the blame and criticism of the sluggish Offence. Whilst Rodgers is the lighting rod, perhaps the front office have the biggest questions to answer in Green Bay. Five of their seven greatest Cap hits this year are for Defensive players. In effect half of their starters should be elite Defensive players. Yet the Defence is conceding on average 21 points per game in 2022. Obviously a high powered Offence could compensate for their leaky Defence. If the Offence could manufacture some long drives (they have the worst 4th Down conversion rate in the league but their average drive time is 14th in the league, so not catastrophic) the Defence would be more rested.
So far however they only average 18 points per game on that side of the ball and here’s why – they really miss Davante Adams as a focal point.
Where the Adams money went
The Packers decided they couldn’t afford to pay Adams and wanted to Franchise tag him. Because they (understandably) have most of their money tied up in the franchise Quarterback. More puzzlingly however Preston Smith and Dean Lowry account for a large chunk too. Smith and Lowry account for $19.5 million of the Packers Cap hit this year. Adams new contract in Las Vegas gives the Raiders a $12.1 million cap hit this year. Smith and Lowry have combined for just 4 Sacks in 2022. Both average 4 tackles per game. As a comparison the Patriots’ 2022 Cap hit for Matt Judon is $16.5 million. On his own he’s made 8.5 sacks with an average of 4 tackles per game.
Safe to say roster construction seems a bit off in Wisconsin. To compound the bizarre way they’ve gone about retaining and releasing players they’ve really whiffed with their early round Draft picks too. The last Wide Receiver they selected in the first round was Javon Walker in 2002. Even when Adams was in Green Bay it seemed like they needed to add some star power to the receiving corps in recent seasons. With Lazard, Cobb, Equanimeous St. Brown and Marquez Valdez-Scantling all looking like second or third Receivers. None of them really stepped up when Adams was injured.
Missing on picks
In 2020 the Packers decided to trade up in the Draft to pick Quarterback Jordan Love. Which rightly upset the Super Bowl winning Quarterback they already had. Missing the opportunity to select Tee Higgins. In 2019 they Drafted Rashan Gary (who’s having a decent season and career) and traded up again to Draft a Safety. They could have used their extra first round pick to take Deebo Samuel. Back in 2017 they Drafted Safety Josh Jones. Who started 12 games and was waived before the 2019 season. This when they could have Drafted Cooper Kupp with the same pick. They’ve had a few chances to help Rodgers cause. They just haven’t taken them.
It is fixable
With just four days before the trade deadline it doesn’t seem like the Packers are in the market to add any new players. So they must be confident the coaches can fix the problems that have surfaced in the last two months. The good news is coaching issues should be the easiest problems to overcome. There’s only one person who needs to fix a coaching problem, the coach. If it was a player problem the solution would involve trying to make sure all 52 people were working together in harmony. However fixing coaching issues can only happen if the right coaches are in place. And if the coaches are still struggling to key in on which problems need solving. Or how they should set about correcting them.
Rodgers is a convenient excuse and his price tag becomes a stick that others can use to beat him when things go wrong. But he is performing well. And it certainly looks that he is being held back by exterior factors. He’s not the one holding the team back. The issues are eminently fixable. The young Receivers have to improve their ball security, right? The play-calling has to become less situational, right? And, if they aren’t going to acquire a Davante Adams replacement they have to make the most of having two elite Running Backs and a relatively mobile Quarterback, right?
If you enjoyed this article you can find more from Rhys Knott here.
Banner Image: Rodgers feels the pain at the moment. Image from nj.com
