Pro Bowl Snubs by Jake Austin

Pro Bowl Snubs by Jake Austin
Reading Time: 5 minutes.

Pro Bowl Snubs: who should have been in?

The NFL announced the rosters to represent the AFC and NFC at the updated Pro Bowl games in February this week. This after a vote from fans, coaches and players. The league’s celebration of its best players will have an updated look this year too. The traditional all-star game has been replaced by a week-long showcase of players’ skills that is instead highlighted by a focus on flag-football. Being chosen to a Pro Bowl is always an important moment in a player’s career.

Not only because of the financial incentives which are often written into contracts for their selection. But also as it represents a player reaching the top of their profession. Despite the range of players selected, roster spots are limited. Meaning deserving players will unfortunately miss out every year. Although we can only offer commiserations to those who were not included, it is still worth pointing out players who have performed at a high level this season. And perhaps should have received stronger consideration for a place on the Pro Bowl roster.

NFC Pro Bowl snubs

Christian McCaffery – RB – San Francisco 49ers

CMC was left out of the Pro Bowl roster behind a trio of NFC East running backs. Saquon Barkley, Tony Pollard and Miles Sanders. Whilst all three have had impressive seasons, McCaffery’s absence from the team is for me the most egregious across both conferences. Not only does he lead all NFC running backs in all-purpose yards with 1,578. But he has also run, caught and passed for scores as the focal-point of a dangerous 49ers offense.

Javon Hargrave – DT – Philadelphia Eagles

The Eagles have the most players from any team selected to the pro bowl with 8. However the level of play sustained by Javon Hargrave this year demonstrates that Philadelphia deserved to send a total of at least 9 players to Vegas for the Pro-Bowl games. He has posted a career-high 10 sacks from his interior position on the defensive line. Tied with Chris Jones for the second most sacks by a DT this season across the entire league. He is a glaring omission from the NFC roster.

Amon-Ra St. Brown – WR – Detroit Lions

The performances of St. Brown as the first option for an explosive Detroit offense that has repeatedly blown opposing defenses out of the water this season make it hard to feel that he is not deserving of a Pro Bowl appearance in February. He missed a few games earlier in the year due to injury. Since then though St. Brown has recovered to 10th in the NFL. With almost 1,000 receiving yards. And with his 89 receptions ranking 6th in the league. Plus he stands second in the NFL in receptions that resulted in first down, behind only Justin Jefferson.

Justin Fields – QB – Chicago Bears

As the current best rushing QB in the league, Fields has become one of the most entertaining young stars in football and it is a hard pill to swallow that Fields will not receive any recognition for his outstanding play this year. In a campaign that has seen him become just the third quarterback in NFL history to rush for 1000 yards in a season, and put him within touching distance of the QB record for rushing yards in a season, Fields certainly makes a convincing case that the Bears should not be one of two teams with no players nominated to the Pro Bowl this year.

Dre Greenlaw – LB – San Francisco 49ers

Greenlaw has been a key centrepiece for one of the top defenses this year, with only Bobby Wagner having a higher PFF grade among Linebackers. He also ranks highly amongst NFC Linebackers in tackles (5th), Run Stops (2nd) and passer rating allowed (6th). Although the nomination of teammate Fred Warner undermines Greenlaw’s campaign for a Pro Bowl nod, it has been the combination between the two that has made the 49ers D so effective this year.

AFC Pro Bowl snubs

Tua Tagovailoa – QB – Miami Dolphins

Tua’s absence from the the initial AFC Pro Bowl roster came as a surprise to many. Especially after he received the most fan votes for any player in the league. But he was passed over for a spot to make way for Patrick Mahomes, Josh Allen, and Joe Burrow. It’s not the case that Tua has performed poorly this year. Actually he’s been the most efficient passer in the league. Leading all quarterbacks in Passer Rating, TD:INT ratio, Yards/attempt, Yards/completion and Pass TD/attempt. It is just that he happens to be in a conference with the three best quarterbacks in the league ahead of him. Who each rank in the top 5 in the NFL in yards and touchdowns and have played themselves into the MVP conversation.

Alex Highsmith – OLB – Pittsburgh Steelers

As I pointed out earlier in the season, despite not being one of the league’s better known players, Highmsmith has made a name for himself this year as the Steelers’ most disruptive Defensive lineman. Not only does Highsmith lead the NFL in forced fumbles with 5, he also leads his team in both sacks and TFLs, with his 11 sacks also tying him with Chris Jones for 4th most in the AFC. Highsmith’s exclusion from the Pro Bow roster is particularly troublesome given how substantially he has outperformed his teammate T.J Watt, who was selected despite injury struggles limiting him to record only 4 sacks in just 7 games.

Austin Ekeler – RB – Los Angeles Chargers

Like Tua, Ekeler is unfortunate to not be named to the pro-bowl because of the stacked level of talent in his conference, as ahead of him lie the league’s top three leading rushers in Josh Jacobs, Derrick Henry and Nick Chubb. Ekeler’s rushing numbers don’t compare to those three elected over him, but he should still be recognised for his significant contribution in the passing game, with his 95 receptions ranking 4th in the league. Additionally, Ekeler is tied with Jamal Williams for total touchdowns with 14 and leads the league in YAC by almost 200 yards, making him a deserving pro-bowler.

Matt Milano – LB – Buffalo Bills

Milano has been a central figure for the AFC leading Bills this season. His crucial play on the field has certainly warranted a pro bowl nod. Milano has done it all this year for the Bills D. Acting as a crushing tackler, and effective blitzer. Whilst also being excellent in pass coverage. His importance to the league’s second best scoring defense makes his omission especially disappointing.

Justin Simmons – FS – Denver Broncos

Simmons, like Milano, has been central to one of the NFL’s best defensive units. But has been overlooked despite his high level of play. With 5 interceptions, Simmons is tied with 3rd most in the league. And has been a central piece of a suffocating Broncos Defense. A D that ranks within the top 5 in terms of total yardage, passing yardage, and points allowed. Simmons is unfortunate that only one free safety from each conference is selected to the Pro Bowl. And that he was up against the Steelers’ Minkah Fitzpatrick, who is having another stellar year.

Banner Image: Should the Lions Amon-Ra St Brown have been selected to the Pro Bowl? Image from si.com

If you enjoy Jake’s writing you can find more from him here.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Back to top
%d bloggers like this: