Can Minshew deliver for the Eagles? By Rhys Knott

Can Minshew deliver for the Eagles? By Rhys Knott
Reading Time: 4 minutes.

Does Gardner Minshew spell the end of the Eagles chances?

Imagine if somebody told you the Eagles had dominated the NFC East with a young and contentious starting quarterback. Right up until the last three games of the regular season when the quarterback suffered a serious injury. You’d probably think you’d somehow been transported back in time to 2017. But here we are. Jalen Hurts’ sprained shoulder doesn’t seem as serious as Carson Wentz’s ACL tear was five years ago. But the team and the player don’t seem to be on the same page about his recovery time.

If Hurts isn’t able to play against the Saints in week 17 then the 2017 comparison continues as their fate rests in the hands of their backup quarterback. Five years ago, it was Nick Foles guiding them into the post season. And to two close wins in the early rounds of the playoffs before they absolutely pounded the Patriots in Super Bowl LII. This time round the Eagles fate will depend on Minshew-mania. As everyone’s favourite mustachioed pass throwing pixie Gardner Minshew assumes the signal calling responsibilities. Leading into the 2017 season, the 28-year-old Foles had a 20-16 record as a starter. Minshew will be just 26 as he attempts to steer the Eagles’ ship to calmer waters. He has only won eight games as a starter (although nobody could have won in Jacksonville when he was there) and he’s lost 15 times.

Minshew brings something different

According to their pen pics Minshew is actually two pounds heavier than Jalen Hurts. But they are not similar in playing style. Hurts was described as one of the best running backs in the SEC during his College career even though he was playing quarterback. Minshew is a capable runner, but he doesn’t have the physicality Hurts brings to the running game.

Hurts averages 53.4 run yards per game in 2022. And his 747 yards make up 32% of the team’s rushing yards. Hurts leads the team in rushing touchdowns with 13 of their 31. Minshew’s only rushed six times this season. (Two of those attempts were him taking a knee to ice games!). Coach Sirianni probably doesn’t want to risk another quarterback getting injured so he might not run Minshew much going forward. Minshew did score on a quarterback sneak against the Cowboys. But his backup Ian Book has only played in one NFL game in his career. So the Eagles will probably try to wrap Minshew in cotton wool whenever possible.

Without Hurts’ running threat there will be a greater emphasis on Miles Sanders carrying the ball. When Hurts has played Sanders has averaged fewer than 16 carries per game. Against the Cowboys he carried 21 times. While Kenneth Gainwell joined in with four carries, and Gainwell also caught four passes.

A different favourite target

Minshew’s favourite target on Saturday was DeVonta Smith. Who caught 12 passes, two of which went for touchdowns. Hurts’ favourite receiver in 2022 has been AJ Brown. But Philadelphia are in the privileged position of having two receivers who can regularly separate from defenders and turn catches into big plays. Tight End Dallas Goedert is the Eagles short to mid route specialist. His three catches against the Cowboys went for 67 yards. Goedert is averaging 61.1 yards per game and as it’s really just him and the running backs who provide a safety valve option for the quarterback. You could argue he’s the key to the Eagles offence.

Over the course of their young careers both Minshew and Hurts have similar pass completion rates. Minshew’s being slightly better at 63% compared to Hurts’ 62.5% But Hurts has really benefitted from the addition of A.J Brown this year. And in 2022 his completion rate is 67.3% (the sixth best in the NFL) so Minshew will need to step up his game if he plays more. He has only attempted 44 passes so far this season but he’s completed just 59.1% of them.

Philadelphia’s Christmas giveaways

In week 16 Minshew threw two interceptions. Which is understandable for a quarterback who had only attempted just four passes all season until the 24th of December. But both came when Quez Watkins was outfought by the defender. The low number of interceptions Hurts has thrown in 2022 has been one of the foundations of the Eagles offence though. Hurts’ interception rate is 1.2% this year (behind only Daniel Jones). Minshew should probably avoid throwing to Watkins going forward.

Philadelphia’s real problem on Christmas Eve was fumbles. Minshew was credited with two and Sanders took the blame for another. But Minshew’s were both at the mesh point between quarterback and running back. It looked like the sort of issue that can be ironed out with reps so you imagine they’ll be practicing it a lot this week. Either that or Sirianni will take the run-option plays off the play sheet this week.

The real issues may not be at quarterback

The Eagles did put up 34 points on a Dan Quinn defense this week. So they should be fine going forward. And the small errors that occurred this week were pretty normal for a quarterback who hadn’t started a game since the 8th of January (coincidentally against Dallas too).

There are bigger problems for the Eagles than who starts at quarterback heading for the playoffs. The defense has conceded an average of 27.3 points per game in the last three weeks. While Lane Johnson, who is probably the best left tackle in the NFL, has an abdominal tear. He’s ruled out for the rest of the regular season. Beyond that the prognosis seems unclear. But it appears to be a difficult injury for a lineman to play through.

Banner Image: Gardner Minshew is stepping up to lead the Eagles. Image from yahoo.com

If you enjoyed this article you can find more from Rhys Knott here.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Back to top
%d bloggers like this: