
Expectation
The atmosphere was hostile, the weather was inhospitable and the officiating was certainly questionable. But despite all that it was a very even matchup. Before Sunday the Bengals had beaten KC three straight times. Some Cincinnati players were even lobbying for the stadium to be named after Joe Burrow! So went wrong for the Bengals?
Until Sunday Joe Burrow had an 8-0 record in “cold weather games”, when the temperature was below 40 degrees Fahrenheit. Headed into the last two minutes in Kansas City it looked like that record could be extended. Poor punt coverage and a complete loss of discipline on defense killed that hope stone dead. There are definitely some questions Ron Torbert and his crew should answer though. Bengals players seemed to be flagged for the smallest infraction. Kansas City players seemed to benefit from “home field advantage” as far as officiating decisions were concerned.
Reality
Failure to establish the run, or more pertinently the inexplicable plan to abandon it almost immediately was the major issue. Kansas City sacked Burrow five times and the Bengals seemed shocked by this. 12 months ago, in the playoffs Burrow was only sacked once. Running the ball to fatigue the opposing defensive front usually slows down a pass rush.
In the previous AFC Championship game Joe Mixon played 75% of their snaps and rushed 21 times, this time out he played just 35% of their snaps and only carried eight times. In total the Bengals ran the ball 27 times for 116 yards last year but this time they only managed 71 yards from 17 attempts.
Joe Burrow was actually the Bengals most successful runner with 30 yards on four runs. One of which seemed designed and saw him gain 16 yards but that didn’t come until the third quarter. Despite the vast open space he had to run into that was the designed quarterback run they called.
Samaje Perine was their most powerful runner, he averaged 4.4 yards per carry. Somehow he was only given five chances to carry the ball.
But what if you can’t run the ball?
The slight obsession with throwing screen passes to Ja’Marr Chase instead of using the running backs to catch passes played right into the Chiefs’ hands. Their good young defensive backs held Chase to just 12.5 yards per reception. The Chiefs linebackers traditionally struggle in matchups against “11 personnel” so short throws to running backs and tight ends are normally more effective.
Perine & Mixon only caught six passes between them and only managed 19 yards. In last year’s AFC Championship game Mixon and Perine also caught six passes between them, but they went for a total of 71 yards.
In the previous playoff meeting back in January 2022 Zac Taylor featured tight end Drew Sample on 90% of Bengals’ snaps. Sample has been on IR since week 5, but Hayden Hurst has stepped up in his absence.
Since week 5 Hurst made 47 receptions for a total of 414 yards, on Sunday he had four catches for just 37 yards. The Bengals only lost two regular season games when Hurst recorded six receptions and tight ends have a 65% catch rate against Kansas City in 2022.
Only four teams conceded more touchdowns to tight ends than the nine the Chiefs allowed (none of those teams made the playoffs). Hurst only played 73% of the Bengals offensive snaps this time round. That was probably a result of the Chiefs pass rush ruining the Bengals plan on offence. The only pass catchers to play more than Hurst were Chase and Higgins but they dropped seven targets between them.
Discipline Issues
Another major difference between last season’s Championship game and this was the number of penalties. It was an issue for both teams though. Last time Bill Vinovich’s crew threw six flags in total. Four on the Bengals for 30 yards and just two on the home team for 11 yards. This time out there were 13 total penalties which is never a good look in a playoff game (there were only 10 in total in the Cowboys @ 49ers game last week and that was a physical battle) and the Bengals were on the wrong side of them. The Bengals nine penalties cost them 71 yards. The Bengals averaged just 5.2 penalties per game all season. The Chiefs averaged 4.9 so it’s odd Cincinnati doubled their average and Kansas City landed right on theirs.
Ultimately a combination of strange play calling allied to their bizarre refusal to cover Marquez Valdes-Scantling was what went wrong for the Bengals and cost them a shot at back-to-back Super Bowl appearances. MVS had his first 100-yard game since week 7 and his first 100-yard playoff game since 2020 for Green Bay. As long as they’ve got Joe Burrow who has only lost two playoff games in his entire life, they’ll be a perennial challenger in the AFC. The only question is how long will he want to take the sort of punishment that Bengals offensive line sends his way?
